Hardbacks versus paperbacks

The St Kilda LR book club had a lively debate a few weeks back on their preferences between hardback books and paperbacks.


plusses for hardcovers:

• hardcovers feel genuine, paperbacks feel 'copied'
• paperbacks are bendy and can go out of shape really easily, their corners bend and break apart
• hardcovers are collectible things
• hardcovers can resist wind, they are stronger if you drop them and they are more waterproof
• paperbacks soak up water and break apart
• hardcovers are better because they look better and publishers put more effort into their front cover
• they are much more hardy, they are easier to take care of and they keep looking good.

plusses for the paperbacks:

• hardcovers are more expensive
• hardcover extra covers (dust jackets) get wrinkled and they’re annoying and you have to throw them out
• hardcover corners are pointy and sharp
• if you drop a hardcover you can hurt your toes
• paperbacks are easier to hold, not so heavy
• paperbacks don’t hurt as much if somebody hits you over the head with one!
• if burning, paperbacks don’t let off as much poisonous fumes!!!

Seems pretty even to us - what do you think? Leave a comment below, or why not vote in the poll (you can find that on the left of the screen.)

Leave a comment

Got something to say? Want to comment on the blog? Want us to add something to the blog? We'll be moderating the comments before they get published, so please respect the space. Swearing won't be published! Nor will comments without your first name and age.

We're looking forward to hearing from you so leave your comments below, or on any post. If you want to review something not here already, why not email us - library@portphillip.vic.gov.au - just put Lightning Readers in the subject line and we'll add your review to the blog (but don't forget your name and a rating out of 5).